The congregation was formed in 1895 and worshipped in two prior buildings before hiring the eminent architect Clarence H. Johnston to design this church in 1908. A beautifully maintained example of the late 19th century Carpenter Gothic style, the building contains all the elements associated with this style including a corner tower topped with a witches’ hat spire, pointed-arched Gothic windows, and delicate filigreed trim. The building is now occupied by St. Paul Fellowship.