This congregation was organized in 1889 by members who withdrew from Shiloh Presbyterian. They held their first meetings in the Odd Fellows Hall at 2320 Harrison St. (now Central Avenue), and in 1890 built a church at 26th Ave. and Taylor St. NE. This building was later sold to the Philadelphia Assembly. In 1925, Shiloh Presbyterian and Bethany Congregational merged back together, becoming Shiloh Bethany Presbyterian Church, and the congregation worshipped in the Shiloh building at 944 24th Ave. NE.